Metal Gear Solid

Steam/PC
PC
CommentGo to game page

Metal Gear Solid: What Worked Then and What Holds Up Today

15 original professional reviews · 5 editorial retrospectives · original reviews 1998–1999 · retrospectives 2017–2023

The cardboard box is one of the ways Solid Snake tries to slip past the guards at Shadow Moses. Around him are cameras, soldiers and a nuclear threat; moments later, the game may stop to talk about war, identity or trust. Metal Gear Solid brings these things together in a stealth adventure that frequently changes pace. Its value lies in how it connects actions, characters and surprises, but forgiving difficulty and lengthy conversations were already being criticized at release.

We compared a selection of authoritative international reviews from the time with five later readings of the original PlayStation game. The comparison distinguishes strengths that remain convincing from limitations already recognized at launch, without treating retrospectives as the opinions of all players.

Consensus map

From original reviews to later reassessments

What remains convincing, and where time changes expectations.

Stealth
Original reviews

Strong tension; difficulty disputed.

Later reassessments

Equipment and environments still appreciated.

What changedDecisions remain interesting; mistakes remain forgiving.

Controls and camera
Original reviews

Much praise, some genuine friction.

Later reassessments

Learning unfamiliar rules matters.

What changedThe fit with the rooms supports the restrictions.

Bosses and surprises
Original reviews

Variety and invention widely praised.

Later reassessments

Encounters retain a strong identity.

What changedTheir value extends beyond the initial surprise.

Story and pacing
Original reviews

Strong involvement; sometimes excessive dialogue.

Later reassessments

More attention to identity, war and control.

What changedThemes receive more attention; interruptions remain.

The two editorial groups remain separate. Retrospectives aren’t a sample of the player audience.

Stealth: tension works even when guards aren’t infallible

At Shadow Moses, you leave traces even when you don’t fire a shot. A guard can notice footprints in the snow, hear a noise and leave their patrol route to investigate. You can wait for them to turn around, crawl under an obstacle or lure them away by knocking on a wall. Metal Gear Solid builds its stealth around these small decisions: study a space, find an opening and try to cross it without turning the situation into a firefight. The radar helps by showing positions and which way guards are looking, but that reassurance disappears when an alert begins.

Original reviews frequently praised this balance between observation and the fear of being spotted. Rooms don’t need to be huge to give you something to figure out: a camera, a narrow passage or a noisy surface can change your route. The game makes the consequences of your actions clear and encourages you to use the environment. The cardboard box fits that same approach. It’s an absurd idea in the middle of a military operation, but it answers the same question as the rest of your equipment: how can you get past an obstacle without confronting it directly?

The disagreement mostly concerns what happens after a mistake. GameSpot finds it too easy to escape the guards and treats that as a weakness in the challenge. IGN’s second opinion instead appreciates stealth that gives you room to recover. These aren’t incompatible descriptions: both recognize a relatively forgiving game, but their expectations differ. If you want an alert to disrupt the mission for a long time, being able to return to normal quickly makes discovery less threatening. If you want to try a solution without constantly restarting, that same flexibility encourages experimentation.

Later reassessments retain their appreciation for using noise, cover and equipment. They also recognize that the radar provides considerable reassurance and can draw your attention away from the environment towards the little map. Tension therefore partly depends on how you choose to play: simply following vision cones isn’t the same as exploring everything a room allows. Calling the guards smart or stupid isn’t enough to explain the result; what matters is how interesting they make the decision before you move.

The stealth works because it gives you useful information and several ways to act within clearly defined spaces. Recovering easily makes discovery less threatening, especially once you know the rules, but also lowers the cost of trying something different. Its strength is the satisfaction of planning and carrying out a solution; the simulation of a relentless manhunt is much less convincing.

Original reviews — 1998–1999

Stealth and guards

Later reassessments — 2017–2023

Stealth and guards
Positive

GamesRadar+

Mixed

Goomba Stomp

Controls and camera: learning a game built around individual rooms

Snake moves through three-dimensional environments, but the main view often remains overhead. You can stop and look around in first person, or press against a wall for a better perspective. You don’t have the freedom to move the camera continuously as you do in many later games. Before crossing a room, you therefore need to gather information with the tools available, then act within that framing. The radar and the ability to peek are parts of the system, rather than simple assists added to a modern control scheme.

Several reviews from 1998–1999 describe this arrangement positively. They appreciate the camera angles, the shift between movement and observation, and the handling of items. The system lets you do quite a lot with a relatively simple controller: hide, strike, drag a guard, switch equipment and prepare a shot. Some actions require a particular combination of inputs, however, so knowing the buttons really matters. The initial training serves a practical purpose, letting you learn without simultaneously following a story scene or avoiding a patrol.

The original criticisms prevent us from describing these controls as if they were perfect for everyone. MeriStation reports camera problems, while GamePro likes the menu handling but criticizes the absence of a custom controller configuration. These are different limitations. In the first case, you may struggle to see what you need; in the second, you have to accept a fixed button layout. Other reviews also raise objections to the controls, even when their overall assessment of the game is very favorable.

The retrospectives help distinguish an unfamiliar convention from an automatic flaw. Goomba Stomp’s defense of the controls starts with their fit with the environments. Stopping to gather information can feel restrictive today, but it supports the rhythm of observation and movement around which the rooms are built. That doesn’t erase the friction reported at launch: it explains why changing one function can also change a challenge. Adding freedom doesn’t necessarily improve the same encounter if that encounter was designed around more limited possibilities.

The controls and camera work well when you’re willing to learn this way of understanding a space. Being able to observe before acting compensates for several restrictions in the viewpoint, while the compact environments give the available actions a purpose. Genuine rigidity remains, along with situations in which the framing helps less than it should: learning the system has value, but it doesn’t make every control problem irrelevant.

Original reviews — 1998–1999

Controls and camera

Later reassessments — 2017–2023

Controls and camera
Positive

Goomba Stomp

Bosses and surprises: variety comes from changing the rules

The mission doesn’t just send you against increasingly large patrols. Major encounters change the problem you need to solve: a long-range duel asks something different from hand-to-hand combat, and a threat searching the arena for Snake calls for another way of using the space. Bosses therefore give your equipment different purposes. The game can demand precision, patience, movement or an insight, without reducing every fight to draining the health of a tougher enemy.

Original reviews appreciate this variety and how distinctive the opponents remain. Their appearance isn’t the only thing that matters. Weapons, behavior and personalities set one scene apart from the next, while the story gives them time. That connection makes the fight more meaningful: the opponent is someone you’ve learned to recognize, rather than an anonymous obstacle at the end of a room. The variety of the action also helps explain why several enthusiastic reviews don’t find a mission set in a relatively compact base repetitive.

The most memorable ideas directly involve the person holding the controller. Psycho Mantis challenges your usual habits when facing a boss, while the reference to the game’s case sends you outside the screen to find information. On the original PlayStation, these ideas use objects and functions physically in front of you. The controller, its vibration and the memory card become part of the experience. The game treats your presence as something it can build a surprise around, without abandoning the fiction of the mission.

Comparing EGM with Multiplayer.it shows how stable this appreciation has remained. The former already recognized the hardware-related inventions at launch; the latter returns to the bosses and the way the game surprises the person in front of the console. Retrospectives didn’t invent the value of these moments after they became famous. What changes is the chance of encountering them without prior knowledge: a surprise discussed for years can lose some of its effect while leaving the underlying idea intact.

Variety also comes at a cost. Later in the game, directed action sequences increase and the room for freer infiltration shrinks. If patrols interested you most, that acceleration takes time away from the activity introduced at the beginning. It’s a change in structure, rather than proof that individual bosses are weak: the game shifts the center of the experience as it carries the story towards its conclusion.

Bosses and surprises are among the most successful elements because they change what you need to understand and give encounters an identity. Their quality depends on distinctive rules and situations as well as surprise. The result is a varied mission that doesn’t maintain the early areas’ emphasis on infiltration all the way to the end.

Original reviews — 1998–1999

Bosses and interaction

Later reassessments — 2017–2023

Bosses and interaction

Story and Codec: strong involvement, real interruptions

Stopping the nuclear threat also means working out who’s telling you the truth. The people you contact through the Codec don’t just explain your next objective: they have personalities, information to hide and different relationships with Snake. The mission therefore continues even when you stop to listen. The game alternates infiltration with conversations and scenes that change the meaning of what you’ve just done. This isn’t a separate story attached to an action route that would work just as well with any excuse for the mission.

At release, the connection between storytelling, direction and characters attracted widespread enthusiasm. Reviews recognized a story capable of sustaining curiosity and tension, with opponents and supporting characters gaining importance as the mission progressed. The feeling of taking part in an action film was frequently presented as a strength. That description didn’t explain everything, however: the game also involved you through actions, surprises and the information you chose to seek out. Some of its storytelling already came from the relationship between Snake and the person controlling him.

Objections to the dialogue were equally real. PSM USA appreciated the story but found some passages long-winded or unnatural, and noted that the plot could become too complex. GamePro particularly criticized early interruptions offering obvious advice. The problem varies from scene to scene: a conversation can be interesting but too long for that moment, or stop the game without telling you anything useful. Skipping everything doesn’t resolve the relationship between narrative and pacing, because it also means giving up a central part of the experience.

Later reassessments devote more attention to war, identity and personal freedom. SpazioGames reads the conflict partly through the way characters are used by those in power. Kotaku’s essay questions violence and control. These pieces foreground issues already present in the game that a launch review might have explored less extensively. They don’t show that every conversation has improved with age: they add reasons to listen without erasing criticisms of the delivery.

The useful comparison is how much a scene gives back for the time it takes. A conversation can complicate your judgment of an opponent and give a fight another meaning; a call repeating an instruction you already understand mainly makes you wait. Even when the story connects these scenes, they aren’t all equally effective. Rich themes don’t make every explanation or repetition necessary.

The story works because it connects the mission, its characters and Snake’s choices, giving weight to what happens between objectives. The limitation is a rhythm that frequently stops and sometimes insists on a point longer than necessary. It’s worth following, but narrative quality shouldn’t be used to deny how much time the game asks you simply to listen.

Original reviews — 1998–1999

Story and pacing

Later reassessments — 2017–2023

Story and pacing

Length and backtracking: the disagreement was already there

Shadow Moses is a place you cross repeatedly, rather than a continuous succession of entirely new environments. Collecting equipment may require returning to an area you’ve visited, while new possibilities encourage you to check places you previously couldn’t reach. This builds familiarity with the base, but also exposes the experience to repetition. Once you know a route, crossing it again can be a test of what you’ve learned or an interval to endure before the next scene.

Length is where original reviews disagree most clearly. Some consider the mission too short; others place considerably more value on returning to the game. The balance between time spent acting and time devoted to cutscenes and dialogue also affects the judgment. A campaign can feel substantial as a story and more limited in the amount of new infiltration it offers. Both observations can coexist without being corrected by a single estimate of the hours needed to finish.

The contrast between GameSpot and IGN is particularly clear. The former treats brevity as a limitation, while the latter defends length and replayability. Reviews placing more value on a second run point to secrets, different ways to proceed and the opportunity to see another ending. That doesn’t mean everyone should restart: it means some of the value lies beyond the first conclusion. If a single playthrough is all you want, that additional value can’t automatically compensate for feeling that you’ve seen too few new situations.

Even favorable assessments of length shouldn’t become precise promises. A reviewer may spend longer exploring, learning the rules or struggling with particular sections. That time describes a playthrough, rather than a property identical for everyone. Counting the two discs or pointing to the number of endings isn’t enough to measure the amount of game: what matters is what you do and how much changes when you repeat it.

The retrospectives mainly add a judgment about returning through the base. Goomba Stomp defends these trips as opportunities to know the environments better and collect equipment, while recognizing that the later stages reduce the scope for infiltration. That supports the continuity of Shadow Moses, rather than providing a modern measure of length. The small group of later pieces doesn’t establish whether the campaign is generally considered long or short today.

The compact structure makes the base recognizable and allows a more informed second run, but not every return offers an equivalent discovery. Replayability has real value if you want to explore equipment and routes more deeply; if you stop at the first ending, brevity and some repeated journeys remain genuine limitations. The game has good reasons to send you back, but those reasons don’t compensate for every moment when you’d rather move forward.

Original reviews — 1998–1999

Length and replayability

The selected reassessments don’t examine this theme consistently enough to support a second bar.

Atmosphere: images and sounds put you inside the base

A footstep matters because it can attract a guard. Music changes how you experience an alert, while camera framing can prepare you for a threat before you face it. In Metal Gear Solid, presentation works alongside the rules: it doesn’t merely accompany the action, but helps you understand danger and makes your surroundings more distinctive. Snow, metal, corridors and industrial spaces give the base a clear personality through small details too.

Contemporary reviews were particularly impressed by the audiovisual execution. Comparisons with cinema also concerned framing and giving characters presence, rather than simply the number of scenes. Character models had obvious limitations, but gestures, voices and direction could sustain an emotional moment. The result didn’t depend on a perfectly realistic face. It depended on a character being able to communicate fear, confidence or exhaustion with the means available.

Voice acting needs to remain in the context of the versions being reviewed, however. Much of the praise in English-language reviews concerns the English performances; it can’t automatically become a judgment of every localization. Jeuxvideo.com, which examines the French version, appreciates the sound but notes voices that can resemble cartoon performances. That’s a specific limitation alongside a favorable assessment of the atmosphere. Speaking as if the voice acting were identical for everyone would conceal a documented difference between sources.

On the technical side, GamePro describes frame-rate drops and slowdown in some observation and aiming views, alongside polygon imperfections. These criticisms concern the original execution, rather than how a modern rerelease operates. Strong direction and visual design don’t remove a slowdown when you’re trying to track a target. Even a highly successful presentation can have moments when a technical limitation interferes with a concrete action.

Retrospectives continue to appreciate the visual identity, music and strength of the performances above all. They don’t pretend the models have become more detailed. They recognize that the solutions used to express the characters remain effective even when the technology that made them impressive no longer surprises. Time therefore shifts the reason for appreciation: from the perceived technical quality at release to the ability to give places and people character.

The atmosphere clearly works because images, sound and direction strengthen both infiltration and storytelling. Technical problems should remain part of the assessment, but aren’t enough to explain the whole presentation, just as its value doesn’t depend on a comparison with today’s graphics. This is a game in which the base remains distinctive and threatening through what you hear before you see.

Original reviews — 1998–1999

Atmosphere and presentation

Later reassessments — 2017–2023

Atmosphere and presentation

Final verdict

Metal Gear Solid still deserves a recommendation because it gives its equipment a clear purpose and frequently changes the kind of problem you need to solve. Appreciating it today means learning its controls and accepting that storytelling takes up considerable space: these are real conditions, rather than details to ignore because it’s a classic. The main limitations remain forgiving consequences after a mistake, some interruptions and return trips that give back less than they ask of you. None is enough to empty the stealth of its satisfaction or undermine the quality of the encounters, but they help explain what you’re choosing. The reason to return to it still lies in the decisions and situations it creates, alongside its historical importance.

How this analysis was produced

This analysis concerns the original PlayStation Metal Gear Solid. It compares 15 professional reviews published in 1998–1999 with five editorial retrospectives from 2017–2023. Second opinions within the same review count as a single source. Archived copies and the republication of MAN!AC’s historical review provide access to the original texts and don’t count as additional modern reviews.

The two groups remain separate. Theme-level judgments come from the text, rather than overall scores. Bars show the distribution of positions among sources addressing that theme; they aren’t scores, consensus percentages or measures of the entire audience. A minor criticism doesn’t automatically require a negative classification. The modern group is small and includes essays and features of different depth: GamesRadar+ and Multiplayer.it are mainly celebratory, SpazioGames concentrates on narrative themes, while the more extensive reassessments also discuss design. It doesn’t establish a statistical trend over time.

The historical selection includes American, British, French, German and Spanish sources, with English-language coverage predominating. It contains no verified professional Italian review from the time. Reviews of the Japanese import retain the language context of the version examined. The 2000 PC port, Integral, The Twin Snakes and the Master Collection’s technical quality aren’t assessed. No analyzed user-review corpus is included.

Some bibliographic details remain incomplete: the original issue containing MAN!AC’s review, Jeuxvideo.com’s overall score and GameRevolution’s historical scoring scale. These limitations concern cataloging, rather than the availability of the texts used.

Sources consulted Original reviews — 1998–1999
  • GameSpot — Jeff Gerstmann, September 25, 1998; 8.5/10.
  • GameRevolution — October 1, 1998; credited to GR Staff in the current archive. The migrated page displays 9; original scale unverified.
  • Edge — #64, November 1998, pp. 78–80; unsigned; 9/10.
  • CVG — #208, March 1999, pp. 38–41; Alex Huhtala; 5/5.
  • Jeuxvideo.com — Lightman, March 11, 1999; overall score unverified.
  • MAN!AC — Winnie Forster, second opinion by Oliver Ehrle; historical 1999 text republished on August 13, 2019; score of 92 on the verdict page.
  • MeriStation — Emilio Peña, March 30, 1999; 9.5/10. Page updated in 2014.
  • PSX Extreme — May 8, 1999; individual author unverified; 9.9/10.
  • EGM — #113, December 1998, p. 261; Crispin Boyer, John Ricciardi, Dan Hsu, John Davison; four 10/10 scores.
  • GamePro — #113, December 1998, pp. 160–161; Major Mike; graphics 4.5/5, sound 5/5, control 4.5/5, fun factor 5/5; no overall score reconstructed.
  • Next Generation — #48, December 1998, pp. 118–119; unsigned; 5/5.
  • Official UK PlayStation Magazine — #42, February 1999; Daniel Griffiths; 10/10.
  • Arcade — #1, December 1998, p. 126; Rich Pelley; 5/5; Japanese import.
  • IGN — Randy Nelson, second opinion by Doug Perry; October 21, 1998 in the original copy, current URL dated October 22; 9.8/10.
  • PSM USA — #15, November 1998, p. 42; unsigned; 5/5.
Retrospectives — 2017–2023
  • GamesRadar+ — David Meikleham, March 31, 2017; retrospective, unscored.
  • Kotaku — Heather Alexandra, June 6, 2019; retrospective, unscored.
  • SpazioGames — Adriano Di Medio, January 17, 2020; thematic feature, unscored.
  • Goomba Stomp — Renan Fontes, October 18, 2022; retrospective, unscored.
  • Multiplayer.it — Diego Trovarelli, September 3, 2023; 25th-anniversary feature, unscored.

Comments

Sign in to comment

No updates in this view. Follow games or choose another filter.

Scroll to Top